home    archive    search    downloads    subscription    contacts

Belarusian Review

Media Watch

In Belarus, a Slide Toward Eastern Aggression

On Sunday, the nation of Belarus held presidential elections. On Sunday evening, the police officers of Belarus handed out their verdict. By midnight, tens of thousands of people had been chased out of the main square in central Minsk, hundreds had been arrested and hundreds more severely beaten. Young people limped away from demonstrations with broken arms, bloody heads. Seven out of nine Belarusan presidential candidates were in jail.

...Police arrested journalists, too, breaking into offices and shutting down their operations. Later, they also arrested artists and actors at home. Just for good measure, cyber police also shut down Web sites and social networking sites — Twitter, Facebook and their Belarusan equivalents — and blocked access to foreign sites that carried news of the events in Minsk. Borrowing tactics from their counterparts down the road in Moldova, Belarusan special forces — still known, creepily, as the KGB — apparently sent in thugs to join the Election Day demonstrations, break windows in the parliament and throw stones, the better to justify the crackdown.

All in all, it was a stunning display of the regime's weakness: Indeed, the violence that unfolded in the wake of Alexander Lukashenka's fourth presidential election "victory" can only be explained as a sign of the Belarusan dictator's failure. After the polls closed, Lukashenka claimed to have received nearly 80 percent of the vote. But politicians who are that popular have no need to beat, arrest and harass their opponents, send provocateurs into a crowd or shut down Web sites.

And indeed, Lukashenka's true support is thought to be rather lower than 80 percent. Belsat — a Polish-based television station that broadcasts into Belarus — reckons Lukashenka's actual support is closer to 30 percent, based on polls taken over several months.

...It also explains why truckloads of riot police were sent out to wait for demonstrators in central Minsk before they even arrived.

Under these circumstances, Lukashenka's "victory" also means that — after a long flirtation with the liberal West and the authoritarian East — the Belarusan dictator has made his choice. Last month, the foreign ministers of Germany and Poland (yes, I am married to the latter) went to Minsk with an offer: In exchange for free elections, the European Union offered a major aid package, more open borders, and the potential for a deeper economic and political relationship. Since then, however, Lukashenko has repaired his skittish relationship with the Kremlin and signed a oil deal with Moscow, ensuring that his country's old economic model remains at least partly intact.

.... And that, for the moment, is it. Statements will be issued, sanctions might be declared. Lukashenka could have a hard time getting a visa to Berlin or London. But in truth, the West has few carrots to offer unpopular dictators — even unpopular dictators who share borders with Europe — other than free trade and the long-term possibility of integration and economic growth. European foreign ministers cannot guarantee Lukashenka personal wealth. They cannot offer corrupt oil deals.

....This, then, is what the "decline of the West" looks like in the eastern half of Europe: The United States and Europe, out of money and out of ideas, scarcely fund the Belarusan opposition. Russia, flush with oil money once again, has agreed to back Lukashenka and fund his regime. Let's hope it costs them a lot more than they expect.

; This article appeared in
Belarusian Review, Vol. 22, No. 4
Copyright 2010 Belarusian Review
All rights reserved.
Source: Excerpts from the Washington Post, December 21, 2010

Anne Applebaum

Printable Version Counter: 3409
Belarus' Forum
Belarusian Culture
Belarusians Abroad
Chronicle of Events
Legacy of Chernobyl
Media Watch
News Briefs
Culture & Society
Freedom of Religion
Independent Media
Belarus & the World
Human Rights
Politics - Opposition
Politics - Regime
Thoughts and Observations
New Articles
Declaration by the Coordinating Committee of Belarusians of Canada (23.01.2011)
Belarus Police Arrest Opposition Leaders (23.01.2011)
Statement By the Rada of The Belarusian Democratic Republic in Exile
28th December 2010
A backfire in Belarus (23.01.2011)
Wrong Carrot, Wrong Stick (23.01.2011)
No Business as Usual (23.01.2011)
A Nasty Surprise in Belarus (23.01.2011)
StatementBy the Office for a Democratic Belarus (Brussels)
And the Belarusian Institute for Strategic Studies
Demonstration in London (23.01.2011)
Blood and Special Operations in Belarus Politics (23.01.2011)
Belarus: That’s enough democracy (23.01.2011)
The Center for Belarusian Studies (23.01.2011)
In Belarus, a Slide Toward Eastern Aggression (23.01.2011)
BNR Rada Rejects Election Results (23.01.2011)
Opinion - The EU Has no Choice But to Continue Dialogue With Belarus (23.01.2011)
Readers' Favorites
Belarusian Weapons Exports:A Possible Source of Laundered Funds? (15739)
The Exchange Rate Policy for Belarus (15595)
Kitabs, the Unique Phenomenon of the Belarusian Language in "Encyclopedia of the Belarusian language" (15561)
Belarusica at the AAASS Convention (14567)
Vaclav Havel - in Defense of Jakub Kolas Humanities Lyceum (14512)
Putin Doctrine: Immediate Threat to Belarus (14105)
Belarusian Currency: Problems and Perspectives (13975)
Is Lukashenka Winning Back Hearts and Minds? (13618)
DZIADY and Kurapaty Unite the Opposition (13277)
Belarus Represented in the World Book Fair (13267)
Minsk Wants Compensation from Moscow for Abandoning National Currency (13260)
Opposition Forms New Pro-European Alliance (13106)
The Sad State of Agriculture (12738)
EU Aid Misuse Fears (12243)
The Third Wave, or the regimes current tactics in dealing with independent NGOs (11833)